Table 3

Quality assessment instruments

Study designTool
RCTsCochrane Risk of Bias tool37
Economic EvaluationsDrummond and Jefferson checklist38
Case–control studiesCase–control Checklist (CRD report 4)39Newcastle Ottawa Scale40
Case seriesCase Series Checklist (CRD report 4)39
Cohort studiesCohort Study Checklist (CRD report 4)39
Cross-sectional studiesAdapted Newcastle-Ottawa for Cross-Sectional studies, adapted by Herzog et al (2013)41
Decision modelsPhilips Checklist42