Table 4

Results of the risk of bias assessment

Study IDReportingExternal validityInternal validity—biasInternal validity— confoundingTotal
Ament et al22UnclearHighHighHighHigh
Benenson et al23UnclearHighHighHighHigh
Cates24HighUnclearHighHighHigh
Enriquez-Puga et al25UnclearHighHighUnclearHigh
Forsner et al26UnclearLowHighHighHigh
Gerber et al35LowLowHighHighHigh
Higuchi et al27HighHighHighHighHigh
Kelly28HighHighHighHighHigh
Knops et al29HighLowHighHighHigh
Loszadi et al30UnclearHighUnclearHighHigh
McLaws et al31HighLowUnclearHighHigh
Stéphan et al32HighHighUnclearHighHigh
Wakefield et al33HighHighHighHighHigh
Williams et al34HighHighUnclearHighHigh
TotalHighHighHighHighHigh