Article Text
PDF
Abstract
Objective Child maltreatment (abuse and neglect) has established associations with mental health; however, little is known about its relationship with physical functioning. Physical functioning (ie, the ability to perform the physical tasks of daily living) in adulthood is an important outcome to consider, as it is strongly associated with an individual’s ability to work, and future disability and dependency. We aimed to establish whether maltreatment was associated with physical functioning, independent of other early-life factors.
Setting 1958 British birth cohort.
Participants 8150 males and females with data on abuse and who participated at age 50 years.
Outcome measures The primary outcome was poor physical functioning at 50 years (<65 on the Short-Form 36 survey physical functioning subscale). Secondary outcomes included mental health and self-reported health at 50 years.
Results 23% of participants reported at least one type of maltreatment; 12% were identified with poor physical functioning. Neglect (ORadj 1.55, 95% CI 1.24 to 1.93), psychological abuse (ORadj 1.49, 1.17–1.88) and sexual abuse (ORadj 2.56, 1.66–3.96) were associated with poor physical functioning independent of other maltreatments and covariates, including childhood social class, birth weight and childhood illness. Odds of poor physical functioning increased with multiple types of maltreatment (ptrend <0.001); ORadj ranged from 1.49 (1.23–1.82) for a single type to 2.09 (1.53–2.87) for those reporting > 3 types of maltreatment, compared with those with none. Associations of similar magnitude were observed for mental and self-reported health outcomes.
Conclusions Child neglect, psychological and sexual abuse were associated with poor physical functioning at 50 years, with accumulating risk for those with multiple types of maltreatment. Associations were independent of numerous early-life factors and were comparable in magnitude to those observed for mental health and self-rated health. Prevention or alleviation of the ill effects of maltreatment could be an effective policy intervention to promote healthy ageing.
- epidemiology
- child abuse and neglect
- physical functioning
- disability
- mental health
This is an Open Access article distributed in accordance with the Creative Commons Attribution Non Commercial (CC BY-NC 4.0) license, which permits others to distribute, remix, adapt, build upon this work non-commercially, and license their derivative works on different terms, provided the original work is properly cited and the use is non-commercial. See: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/
Statistics from Altmetric.com
Strengths and limitations of this study:
Data were from a large population-based cohort followed from birth to age 50 years, which allowed prospective ascertainment of childhood neglect, early-life covariates and adult outcomes.
Childhood abuse was obtained retrospectively, but 5 years prior to outcome ascertainment, reducing the possibility of recall bias.
Sample reductions due to missing data were addressed using multiple imputation.
Introduction
A rapidly ageing population in Western countries coupled with escalating health and social care costs has led to an urgent need to reduce ill health and disability in later life.1 Physical functioning (ie, the ability to perform the physical tasks of daily living) is strongly associated with future disability, in addition to other important outcomes including hospitalisations, falls, nursing home admissions, higher levels of dependency and mortality.2–4 It is therefore important to understand the determinants of physical functioning and in order to plan effective points of policy intervention, necessary to understand proximal and distal determinants. There is growing evidence that early-life conditions such as socioeconomic position,5 birth weight6 and parental health7 are associated with physical functioning in adulthood, but little is known about the specific influence of child maltreatment (including abuse and neglect) as relatively few studies have been undertaken. Child maltreatment may be an important early-life influence on adult physical functioning as it is associated with long-term morbidity and poor socioeconomic outcomes, including low educational attainment,8 less upward social mobility,9 mental health problems, unhealthy behaviours and chronic diseases,8 10 which in turn are associated with subsequent physical functioning.4 11–15 Evidence on the potential role of child maltreatment is of particular interest because it is not uncommon; in the UK, an estimated 22% of those under 17 report having experienced > 1 form of maltreatment,16 with equally high levels reported in the USA and Europe.8
Existing studies examining associations between child maltreatment and physical functioning in adulthood have relied on cross-sectional samples from USA,17–21 were limited to women19–21 or examined sexual abuse only.21 Few studies have examined neglect, and of those which have, maltreatments were combined so differential effects could not be identified.19 20 Previous work has also combined wide age groups,17–21 which can lead to biased estimates,22 and because studies have accounted for limited19 or no17 18 20 21 early-life confounders, it is unclear whether observed associations are distinct from other childhood factors known to be associated with adult physical functioning. Furthermore, few studies consider the role of potential intermediary factors such as adult mental health or socioeconomic position, in any maltreatment-physical functioning associations. Such gaps in knowledge also apply to other markers of disadvantaged childhood environment such as socioeconomic position5; while the latter is associated with several factors (eg, growth and nutrition) that affect peak physical fitness and capability achieved by early adulthood, the extent to which child socioeconomic position–adult physical functioning associations reflect an influence of maltreatment is unclear.
Therefore, using longitudinal data from a large British birth cohort followed to 50 years, we aimed to establish whether child maltreatment was associated with later physical functioning and to assess whether this association was independent of other early-life factors. International standards for defining physical functioning and disability and links between these concepts have been developed in the WHO’s ‘International Classification of Impairments, Disabilities and Handicaps’ recently revised as the International Classification of Functioning, disability and health (ICF).23 While the ICF provides a comprehensive framework, it has been suggested that the physical functioning subscale of the Short-Form 36 (SF-36)24–26 is a useful tool for measuring mobility disability in epidemiological studies.27 Hence, we used this subscale in our study. To illustrate the magnitude of the relationship between maltreatment and physical functioning, we examined two secondary outcomes, mental health and self-rated health, for which associations with maltreatment are more established.8 28–30 The physical functioning and mental health subscales of the SF-36 have been shown to be relatively distinct,24 25 while self-rated health was included to reflect a broader measure of overall health. Neglect and (different types of) abuse were examined separately (to assess whether there were differential effects on the outcomes) and combined (to assess cumulative burden). We explored to what extent associations between maltreatment and physical functioning were explained by potential intermediary factors including education level, adult smoking, mental health or socioeconomic position. Finally, in respect of other childhood factors, we investigated the relationship between childhood socioeconomic position and adult outcomes in order to assess whether previously documented associations5 are independent of maltreatment.
Methods
The 1958 British Birth Cohort study includes all children born in England, Scotland and Wales during 1 week in March 1958 (n=17 638) and 920 immigrants with the same birth week recruited up to age 16 years.31 Information was collected throughout childhood (birth, 7, 11 and 16 years) and adulthood (23, 33, 42, 45 and 50 years) from individuals, as well as parents, teachers and school doctors (childhood surveys) and nurses (45 years). Of 12 252 invited, 9790 (80%) participated in the 50-year survey (see online supplementary figure S1). Respondents in mid-adulthood were broadly representative of the surviving cohort.32 At 45 years, ethical approval was given by the South-East Multi-centre Research Ethics Committee (MREC ref 01/1/44) and at 50 years, by the London MREC (ref 08/H0718/29). Informed consent was obtained from participants at various sweeps: for example, at 45 years, respondents were given an information booklet before they agreed to participate: they were reassured on the confidentiality of their responses and reminded that they could choose not to answer questions. Respondents gave consent for their information to be deposited at the UK Data Archive and used anonymously for research purposes. Data analysts agreed to comply with the Data Archive’s ‘terms of use’.
Supplementary file 1
![[SP1.jpg]](https://bmjopen.bmj.com/content/bmjopen/7/10/e017900/DC1/embed/inline-supplementary-material-1.jpg?download=true){kind=link}
Childhood neglect and abuse
Neglect was identified at 7 and 11 years from structured interviews with the child’s mother (or father if the mother was unavailable) and from questionnaires completed by their teacher. Eleven indicators of neglect were selected to represent conventional definitions (table 1). Indicators were summed to create a score (range 0–11); those scoring > 3 were classified as neglected (9.6%), in keeping with other prevalence estimates in the UK.8 16
Definition of child maltreatment and representative variables from the 1958 British birth cohort
Physical, psychological, witnessing and sexual abuse to age 16 years were ascertained at 45 years using a confidential Computer-Assisted Self Interviewing questionnaire (table 1). The questionnaire was originally used in the Path Through Life Project,33 details of which are described elsewhere.9
The number of types of maltreatment was summed to create a maltreatment score (range: 0–5) including neglect, physical, psychological, witnessing and sexual abuse.
Adult outcomes
Physical functioning and mental health
Physical functioning and mental health were assessed using the physical functioning and mental health subscales of the SF-36 survey,26 which was administered to participants at 50 years by postal questionnaire.
The physical functioning subscale is a validated 10-item questionnaire measuring the extent to which individuals feel that they are limited in physical activities due to their health.26 34 35 The scale covers a range of severe and minor limitations, including lifting, carrying groceries, climbing stairs, bending, kneeling, stooping and walking moderate distances. Participants were asked to respond on a three-point Likert scale (limited ‘a lot’=1, ‘a little’=2, ‘not at all’=3); scores were summed and then linearly transformed to a scale ranging from 0 to 100, with lower scores representing poorer physical functioning. A cut-off of <65 was used to define poor physical functioning.
The mental health subscale (also known as the Mental Health Inventory-5) is a validated five-item screening questionnaire for mood and anxiety disorders.24 36–38 Participants were asked how much of the time over the past month (‘all’=1, ‘most’=2, ‘good bit’=3, ‘some’=4, ‘little’=5, or ‘none’=6) they had (1) ‘been a very nervous person?’; (2) ‘felt calm and peaceful?’; (3) ‘felt downhearted and low?’; (4) ‘been a happy person’; (5) ‘felt so down in the dumps that nothing cheers you up?’. Scores were reverse coded where appropriate, summed and linearly transformed to a scale ranging from 0 to 100, with lower scores representing poorer mental health.24 As in previous studies,39–41 a cut-off of <52 was used to identify ‘poor mental health’, which had been shown to best satisfy clinical diagnostic criteria for depression.37
Self-rated health
Self-rated health was ascertained during interviews at ages 23, 33, 42 and 50 years. Participants were asked to give an overall assessment of their general health on a four-point scale at 23–42 years (‘excellent’, ‘good’, ‘fair’ or ‘poor’) and a five-point scale at 50 years (‘excellent’, ‘very good’, ‘good’, ‘fair’ or ‘poor’). Less than 5% of participants rated their health as ‘poor’ prior to 50 years; therefore, consistent with others,28 29 we define ‘poor’ as those with a ‘poor’ or ‘fair’ rating, hereafter referred to as ‘poor’ self-rated health.
While the physical functioning and mental health subscales of the SF-36 are two relatively distinct components,24 25 self-rated health represents a broader measure which captures aspects of both physical and mental health.24 42
Covariates
Covariates were identified a priori as early-life factors associated with the outcomes.5–7 These were all prospectively measured: childhood socioeconomic position (father’s occupation, as in table 1), birth weight (adjusted for gestational age), birth order (1, 2, 3, 4+), 7-year household amenities (sharing or lack of a bathroom, lavatory or hot water), 7-year household crowding (> 1.5 people/room), 7-year housing tenure (owner/occupier, renter or other), parental education at birth (both mother and father left school at the minimum leaving age), 7-year childhood physical or cognitive impairment (yes/no), parental chronic illness at 11 years (yes/no) and parental psychiatric illness at 11 years (yes/no). All factors were assessed using parental report, except for birth weight which was ascertained from clinical records.
Potential intermediary factors
Potential intermediary factors have been reported to be associated with both child maltreatment and adult physical functioning, including 23-year smoking8 11 (never, ex, light/moderate, heavy), 23-year psychological distress8 14 41 (score 0–15, assessed using the malaise inventory43), 33-year educational attainment8 15 (no qualifications, CSE/O-level, A-level, degree level or higher) and 33-year socioeconomic position5 9 (professional/managerial, skilled non-manual, skilled manual and partly skilled/unskilled).
Analysis
Logistic regression was used to assess associations between each child maltreatment and physical functioning, mental health and self-rated health at 50 years. For each outcome, we tested interactions between each type of maltreatment and sex; there was little evidence of effect modification; hence, results are presented for sexes combined.
We examined associations with three levels of adjustment. First, we adjusted for sex (model 1). Second, to assess whether associations were independent of other early-life factors, we additionally adjusted for covariates listed above (model 2). Third, because different types of maltreatment often co-occur,44 we mutually adjusted for all types of maltreatment simultaneously (model 3). In supplementary analyses, we examined whether associations were robust in a series of models restricted to weakly correlated maltreatments (pairwise correlation coefficients, r<0.2). To establish whether associations between child maltreatment and self-rated health were evident at younger ages, we repeated the above analyses for all available ages. We examined the cumulative burden of multiple types of maltreatment by assessing associations between number of maltreatment types (0, 1, 2, ≥3) and each outcome. To assess the role of potential intermediary factors (smoking, mental health, education and adult socioeconomic position) in explaining associations between maltreatment and physical functioning, we further adjusted model 3 for each factor in turn. Where appropriate, the above analyses were repeated to assess associations between childhood socioeconomic position and adult outcomes, adjusting for other factors in childhood and potential intermediary factors in adulthood.
Sensitivity analyses were conducted first to test whether results were affected by single parent families; we found that excluding single parent families (5.2%) did not alter associations of interest; thus, results are presented using the full sample. Second, to examine whether associations were robust to choice of cut-off for neglect, we repeated analyses using a more stringent cut-point (> 4, 6.4%). Results confirm associations presented, although with larger ORs for physical functioning and mental health, less so for self-rated health (data not shown).
Eligible participants included all those who participated in the study at 50 years and who also completed the child maltreatment questionnaire at age 45 years (n=8150; see online supplementary figure S1). To minimise data loss, multiple imputation using chained equations45 was used to impute missing data on indicators of neglect (range: 6.4%–17.8%; 91.1% of participants had complete data on > 6 items), physical functioning (9.7%), mental health (9.4%), self-reported health (0.1%) and all covariates (range: 2.9%–15.2%). Imputation models included all study variables in addition to variables which have been identified as predicting non-response in the cohort (internalising and externalising behaviours, and cognition at 7 years).32 Analyses were run across 20 imputed datasets; imputed results were similar to those using observed values so only the former are presented. All analyses were carried out in STATA V.13.1.
Results
Child maltreatment varied from 1.4% (sexual abuse) to 10.4% (psychological abuse); 15% experienced one type of maltreatment and 3% experienced > 3 (table 2). Characteristics of the included sample are shown in online supplementary table S1. The prevalence of those classified as having poor physical functioning and poor mental health were similar (12.0% and 12.4%, respectively), while 16.9% had poor self-reported health. Of those with poor physical functioning, 50% reported that they were ‘limited a lot’ bending, kneeling or stooping; 36% carrying groceries; and 29% walking 100 yards (data not shown).
Supplementary file 2
Prevalence of childhood maltreatment, adult physical functioning, mental health and self-rated health in the 1958 birth cohort (3997 males; 4153 females)
Physical functioning and mental health scores were weakly correlated (r=0.28); only 28% of those with poor physical functioning reported poor mental health. Self-rated health was moderately correlated with physical functioning (r=0.50) and with mental health (r=0.36). Of those with poor-rated health, 46% had poor physical functioning and 33% reported poor mental health.
Table 3 shows that in sex adjusted models (model 1), all types of maltreatment were associated with poor physical functioning at 50 years. Associations attenuated but remained after adjustment for covariates, with ORs ranging from 1.42 (95% CI 1.09 to 1.84) to 3.23 (2.14 to 4.86) for witness and sexual abuse, respectively (model 2). When all maltreatment types were considered simultaneously, associations remained for neglect, psychological and sexual abuse, although ORs reduced to 1.55 (1.24 to 1.93), 1.49 (1.17 to 1.88) and 2.56 (1.66 to 3.96), respectively, whereas associations for physical and witnessing abuse were completely attenuated (model 3). Results were similar to those reported here when we examined associations in models restricted to the least correlated maltreatments (see online supplementary table S2). Except for sexual abuse, maltreatment associations were generally of similar magnitude for mental health and self-rated health at 50 years (tables 3 and 4). For example, ORs for neglect were 1.55 (1.24 to 1.93), 1.43 (1.16 to 1.77) and 1.42 (1.18 to 1.70) for poor physical functioning, mental health and self-rated health, respectively (table 3, model 3).
Associations between child maltreatment and poor physical functioning, mental health and self-rated health at 50 years
Associations (OR, 95% CI) between child maltreatment and poor physical functioning at 50 years, adjusted for adult (23 years) smoking, psychological distress and education level achieved by 33 years
For childhood socioeconomic position, the ORadj of poor physical functioning was 1.27 (1.17 to 1.37) per decrease on the four-point scale (table 3, model 3); comparing the lowest class (IV/V) with highest (I/II) class, the ORadj for poor physical functioning was 2.03 (ie, 1.273)(1.56 to 2.50). Similar associations were observed for self-rated health; however, childhood socioeconomic position was not associated with mental health in model 3.
Associations between maltreatment and physical functioning were only partially attenuated by potential intermediary factors (table 4). The ORadj for neglect reduced from 1.55 (1.24 to 1.93) to 1.29 (1.02 to 1.61) after adjustment for education level, with lesser attenuating effects for mental health and adult socioeconomic position. ORs for sexual abuse remained, although attenuated after adjustment for education and adult socioeconomic position (eg, from 2.56 (1.66 to 3.96) to 2.36 (1.52 to 3.66) after adjusting for the latter). In contrast, ORs for psychological abuse were attenuated only by adjustment for mental health: from 1.49 (1.17 to 1.88) to 1.27 (1.03 to 1.56). As expected, associations between childhood socioeconomic position and physical functioning weakened after adjusting for education (1.27 (1.17 to 1.37) to 1.15 (1.06 to 1.24) per decrease in socioeconomic position) and to a lesser extent adult socioeconomic position.
In covariate adjusted analyses, associations between maltreatment and self-rated health at 50 years were similar in magnitude to those observed at earlier ages (23, 33 and 42 years) (see online supplementary table S3, model 2); for example, ORadj for psychological abuse was 1.65 (1.29 to 2.12) at age 23, and 1.74 (1.47 to 2.06) at 50 years. However, associations were less consistent after simultaneous adjustment for all maltreatments (model 3).
There was a dose–response relationship between number of types of maltreatment and poor physical functioning: covariate adjusted ORs ranged from 1.43 (1.16 to 1.77) for a single type of maltreatment to 2.09 (1.53 to 2.87) for those reporting > 3 types (ptrend <0.001; table 5).
Associations between number of types of maltreatment and poor physical functioning, mental health and self-rated health at 50 years
Discussion
In this large population-based study of child maltreatment and adult health outcomes, we showed several important findings. First, neglect and psychological abuse were associated with higher odds, by approximately 50% of poor physical functioning, while sexual abuse was associated with higher odds of more than twofold. Importantly, these associations were independent of other child maltreatments and covariates including early-life factors linked to physical functioning, such as socioeconomic factors,5 parental health7 and birth weight.6 46 Second, in regard to potential intermediary factors, our findings suggest that adult socioeconomic position is intermediate in associations for neglect and sexual abuse, while for psychological abuse, adult psychological distress is likely to be important. Third, associations between child maltreatment and physical functioning were generally of comparable magnitude to those observed for mental health and self-rated health, even though poor physical functioning and poor mental health represented largely distinct groups. Fourth, there was evidence of an accumulating burden for those experiencing multiple types of maltreatment, with those experiencing > 3 types having twice the odds of poor physical functioning compared with those experiencing none. Finally, childhood socioeconomic position was associated with adult physical functioning, independent of other early-life factors including maltreatment and also of adult socioeconomic position.
Methodological considerations
Our study has several strengths including a long follow-up period (birth to 50 years), and prospectively measured outcomes and covariates, although the possibility of residual confounding cannot be excluded. While our outcomes were self-reported, all have been shown to predict mortality,2–4 47 48 and have been validated against objective assessments of physical performance (eg, grip strength),35 medical conditions24 34 and clinical psychiatric evaluations.24 38 Multiple types of child abuse and neglect were assessed both prospectively and retrospectively; however, as with all methods of ascertainment,8 the measures have limitations. For example, our neglect indicators cover many (eg, failure to ensure a child’s basic physical or educational needs) but not all (eg, failure to ensure a child’s safety) aspects of the conventional definition.8 However, use of a composite score with multiple sources of reporting (ie, parent and teacher) may help to reduce neglect misclassification49; also, we showed that our findings for neglect were robust to choice of cut-point. Retrospective reports of parental abuse provided no information on duration, timing or frequency, and also exclude abuse by non-parents, which could lead to an underestimate of the prevalence.50 Except for sexual abuse, where perpetrators are less likely to be parents,50 our prevalence estimates for abuse and neglect are in line with other reviews.8 16 50 There are concerns that the validity of retrospective reports of child maltreatment could be influenced by current circumstances51; we acknowledge that we cannot rule out this possibility. However, results for self-rated health at different ages suggest that recall bias is unlikely to account for associations observed for outcomes at 50 years: that is, findings for self-rated health at 23 years (many years prior to the reporting of abuse) were generally consistent with those seen for self-rated health at 50 years. It is relevant that measures of child abuse were ascertained 5 years prior to our main outcome, and also that our previous studies have shown expected associations between retrospective reports of abuse and prospectively measured family dysfunction52 and mental health,41 suggesting good construct validity. Finally, there has been attrition in the study sample over time: although respondents in mid-adulthood were generally representative of the surviving cohort, disadvantaged groups were the most likely to be under-represented.32 As expected, child maltreatment groups are more likely to be under-represented in our study: for example, for neglect the prevalence was 9.6% in the study sample versus 12.5% in the childhood sample. However, previous work on potential attrition bias relating to child maltreatment in this cohort suggests that effects are negligible for associations with mental health at 50 years41; even so, the possibility of such bias cannot be ruled out. For missing data, we maximised available data by including all who participated at 50 years who had data on retrospective measures of abuse and followed current guidelines on multiple imputation to avoid sample reduction due to missing data.53
Interpretation and comparison with other studies
Our findings that neglect, psychological and sexual abuse were associated with an increased odds of poor physical functioning at 50 years are largely consistent with previous cross-sectional studies from the USA17–21 which found that adverse childhood experiences,17–19 sexual20 21 and non-sexual abuse20 were associated with poor physical functioning and disability. We make several important contributions to existing literature by showing that observed associations are independent of other early-life factors known to be associated with poor physical functioning in adulthood, such as low birth weight,6 46 poor parental health7 and low socioeconomic position.5 Moreover, to our knowledge, our findings for neglect are novel, as all previous studies have combined neglect with other maltreatments19 20; this is noteworthy because neglect is relatively common,8 16 yet it is often underexamined. In respect of childhood socioeconomic position, our finding of an association with physical functioning that was independent of maltreatment (and also birth weight) suggests that early economic environment contributes to adult outcome separately from these other early-life adversities, that is, socioeconomic position is not a proxy for maltreatment and vice versa.
Previous studies have relied on mixed aged samples17–21; however, we assessed physical functioning at 50 years which is important because those with poor physical functioning at this age are likely to enter a state of disability (ie, the inability to carry out activities needed to function in society) sooner compared with those reporting no or mild limitations.54 Many (50%) of those identified here as having poor physical functioning reported substantial limitation with bending, kneeling or stooping and about a third had limitations carrying groceries and walking a short distance (100 yards). Age 50 years is close to peak earning capacity in the UK55; thus, physical limitations at this age are likely to lead to long-term hardship due to difficulties undertaking paid employment,24 and associated ill health during old age.
There was evidence that neglect, psychological and sexual abuse were independently associated with physical functioning, but not physical or witnessing abuse, suggesting that different maltreatments may have differential effects. Explanations for the lack of association for physical and witnessing abuse are uncertain; however, due to moderate correlations between physical, witnessing and psychological abuse, these findings should be interpreted with caution. For neglect and sexual abuse, our findings relating to potential intermediary factors suggest that associations with physical functioning were partially explained by education level and adult socioeconomic position, which is consistent with our previous work showing unfavourable socioeconomic trajectories in adulthood for these groups.9 In contrast, findings for psychological abuse suggest that the association with physical functioning may be explained partly by psychological distress rather than socioeconomic factors, which is in line with previous work suggesting that depression predicts physical functioning trajectories.14 The childhood socioeconomic position association with physical functioning was most strongly attenuated by education and adult socioeconomic position; however, in contrast to other maltreatments, it was unaffected after adjustment for psychological distress. These findings suggest that different maltreatments, and social disadvantage, may have unique pathways to poor physical functioning; this provides important clues on likely child to adult mechanisms and potential intervention targets. Child sexual abuse and socioeconomic position associations with physical functioning were only partially attenuated following adjustment for smoking, psychological distress, education and adult socioeconomic position, which suggests that other unexamined factors could play an important intermediary role. Our findings confirm previous reports that associations for childhood socioeconomic position remain after allowing for adult socioeconomic position5 and they add new knowledge regarding the likely minor contributory role of adult smoking and psychological distress. Further clues on pathways from child maltreatments to poor physical functioning in adulthood may be gleaned in future studies of potential intermediaries such as chronic health conditions and acquired disabilities.
A novel observation from our study was that, in general, the magnitude of associations between individual maltreatments and mid-adult physical functioning was similar to those for mental health and self-rated health. This finding is important because, in contrast to mental health where the consequences of childhood maltreatment have long been recognised, possible impacts on adult physical functioning have not been fully appreciated. The magnitude of maltreatment–physical functioning associations was not negligible, and comparable to those found in the few other existing studies.10 17 For example, across our three outcome measures, ORs varied between 1.4 and 1.6 for neglect, and 1.5 and 1.8 for psychological abuse, while other studies of non-sexual abuse reported ORs in the region of 1.3–2.4 for disability17 and 1.5–3.1 for depressive disorders.10
In contrast to previous work,21 our findings suggest that sexual abuse has larger associations with physical functioning and self-rated health compared with mental health; however, discrepancies are likely to be due to the low prevalence of sexual abuse or differences in study design. Also, we showed comparable dose–response relationships between the number of types of maltreatment and the three outcome measures, which is consistent with other studies suggesting that greater exposure to adverse childhood experiences (including maltreatment) is linked to higher levels of disability,17 depressed mood,29 41 poor self-rated health,29 long-term sickness absence9 and other health conditions.10 29
Despite the similarity of magnitude of associations in our study across the three outcome measures, it is important to note that the physical functioning and mental health scales captured two relatively distinct constructs: as originally intended in the construction of the SF-36 scales34 and demonstrated in previous work.24 42 Consistent with this, we found weak correlations between physical functioning and mental health, suggesting that associations between child maltreatment and physical functioning and mental health are relatively distinct. As expected, physical functioning and self-rated health were moderately correlated, suggesting that there is overlay in these constructs. Our findings for self-rated health at several ages in adulthood (23 to 50 years) suggest that to some extent associations between child maltreatment and self-rated health emerge in early adulthood and then persist across subsequent decades of life.
Conclusions and implications
Our study suggests that neglect, psychological and sexual abuse have long-term associations with poor physical functioning at 50 years, with accumulating burden for those experiencing multiple types of maltreatment. We contribute to the existing literature by demonstrating that associations were independent of other early-life factors linked to poor physical functioning in later life and by showing that the magnitude of associations for physical functioning was largely comparable to those for mental health and self-rated health. Importantly, those with poor physical functioning and poor mental health are relatively distinct groups. Our results suggest that maltreated children grow up with a higher risk of experiencing problems performing the physical tasks of daily living in adulthood, which is likely to affect economic productivity, and lead to increased risk of disability and poor health at older ages. It has been argued elsewhere that clinicians and others, including policymakers, need to be aware of the later chronic physical and mental health problems associated with child maltreatment,56 and our findings suggest that this also applies to physical mobility and functioning with advancing age. Unless findings such as those shown here are recognised and action taken, opportunities will be missed to prevent detrimental long-term outcomes of child maltreatments. Given the prevalence of maltreatment in the general population and its sizeable association with adult physical functioning, our findings suggest that the prevention of maltreatment and the alleviation of its ill effects could be an effective policy intervention, relevant to all countries with ageing populations.
Acknowledgments
The authors are grateful to the Centre for Longitudinal Studies (CLS), UCL Institute of Education for the use of these data and to the UK Data Service for making them available. However, neither CLS nor the UK Data Service bear any responsibility for the analysis or interpretation of these data
References
Footnotes
Contributors All authors designed and conducted the research. GA performed statistical analyses and drafted the manuscript. SMPP and CP reviewed and revised the manuscript. CP had primary responsibility for final content. All authors approved the final manuscript as submitted.
Funding This research was funded by the Department of Health Policy Research Programme through the Public Health Research Consortium (PHRC) and supported by the NIHR Great Ormond Street Hospital Biomedical Research Centre. The views expressed in the publication are those of the authors and not necessarily those of the NIHR or the Department of Health. Information about the wider programme of the PHRC is available from http://phrc.lshtm.ac.uk. The funders had no input into study design; data collection, analysis and interpretation; in the writing of the report; and in the decision to submit the article for publication. Researchers were independent of influence from study funders.
Competing interests None declared.
Ethics approval Ethical approval for the 45 year survey was given by the South-East Multi-centre Research Ethics Committee (ref 01/1/44) and for the 50y survey by the London Multi-centre Research Ethics Committee (ref 08/H0718/29); informed consent was obtained
Provenance and peer review Not commissioned; externally peer reviewed.
Data sharing statement Cohort data comply with ESRC data sharing policies, readers can access these data via the UK Data Archive at http://www.data-archive.ac.uk/