Article Text

PDF

A survey of social support for exercise and its relationship to health behaviours and health status among endurance Nordic skiers
  1. Paul J Anderson1,
  2. Ralph S Bovard2,
  3. Zhen Wang3,4,
  4. Timothy J Beebe3,4,
  5. Mohammad Hassan Murad1
  1. 1Division of Preventive, Occupational, and Aerospace Medicine, Mayo Clinic, Rochester, Minnesota, USA
  2. 2Department of Occupational and Environmental Medicine Residency, Health Partners, Saint Louis Park, Minnesota, USA
  3. 3Robert D. and Patricia E. Kern Center for the Science of Health Care Delivery, Rochester, Minnesota, USA
  4. 4Division of Health Care Policy and Research, Division of Health Sciences Research, Mayo Clinic, Rochester, Minnesota, USA
  1. Correspondence to Dr Zhen Wang; wang.zhen{at}mayo.edu

Abstract

Objectives Regular exercise is a key component of obesity prevention and 48% of Americans do not meet minimum guidelines for weekly exercise. Social support has been shown to help individuals start and maintain exercise programmes. We evaluated social support among endurance athletes and explored the relationship between social support for exercise, health behaviours and health status.

Design Survey.

Setting The largest Nordic ski race in North America.

Participants 5433 past participants responded to an online questionnaire.

Outcome measures Social support, health behaviours and health status.

Results The mean overall support score was 32.1 (SD=16.5; possible range=−16.0 to 88.0). The most common forms of social support were verbal such as discussing exercise, invitations to exercise and celebrating the enjoyment of exercise. We found that an increase of 10 points in the social support score was associated with a 5 min increase in weekly self-reported exercise (5.02, 95% CI 3.63 to 6.41).

Conclusions Physical activity recommendations should incorporate the importance of participation in group activities, especially those connected to strong fitness cultures created by community and competitive events.

Statistics from Altmetric.com

Strengths and limitations of this study

  • The study characterised patterns of social support among endurance athletes who already participate in a strong fitness subculture.

  • We analysed the strength of the relationship between social support for exercise, health behaviours and self-reported health status.

  • Self-reporting of exercise is an important limitation.

Introduction

More than two-thirds (69%) of Americans are overweight or obese and there is irrefutable evidence that regular physical activity effectively prevents obesity and other chronic diseases such as cardiovascular disease, diabetes, cancer, hypertension, depression and osteoporosis.1 Yet 25% of Americans report no leisure time physical activity, less than half (48%) report that they meet the 2008 physical activity guidelines of >150 min/week, and fewer than 10% meet the physical activity guidelines when measured with actigraphy.2 ,3

In contrast, many citizen endurance athletes participate in fitness cultures that encourage physically active lifestyles associated with high self-reported health status, high prevalence of healthy lifestyle behaviours and remarkably low levels of obesity.4 Social Learning Theory suggests that such social support reinforces self-efficacy (the ability to effectively carry out planned actions) and helps individuals overcome a variety of difficult barriers to behaviour change.5 Sallis applies these concepts to nutrition and physical activity and has created a validated survey in order to analyse the balance between forms of encouragement and discouragement from family and friends.6 Self-efficacy and social support from families and friends may function synergistically to help people start new physical activity programmes, maintain their current regimens and improve their future performance.7 In the light of this, it is plausible that many endurance athletes achieve success through participation in fitness cultures that provide strong social support for their athletic endeavours. To the best of our knowledge, patterns of social support for exercise behaviours among Nordic skiers have not been characterised.

The purpose of this descriptive study was to characterise patterns of social support among endurance athletes who already participate in the fitness subculture supported by The American Birkebeiner Nordic ski race. This study also attempts to generate hypotheses about the relationship between social support for exercise, health behaviours and self-reported health status.

Methods

Study population

The study population included individuals who had ever participated in at least one event sponsored by the American Birkebeiner Ski Foundation. The American Birkebeiner ski race (aka ‘The Birkie’) was founded in 1973 and it is now the largest Nordic ski race in North America attracting over 12 000 participants in 2015. The American Birkebeiner Ski Foundation (ABSF) champions the race as a ‘year round lifestyle choice for outdoor fitness enthusiasts of all levels’. In addition to Nordic ski races, Birkie events now include a fall mountain-bike marathon, spring and summer running races on the Birkebeiner trail, family centred ski weekends, skijoring events (skiing while pulled by a dog) and a fat-tire on-snow bicycle race. The hallmark Birkebeiner events are the 54 km classic ski race and the 50 km skate ski race, as well as the 25 km Korteloppet which may be completed in skate or classic technique. Each participant in a Birkie event receives a unique ‘Birkie ID number’ which was coupled with their email address to form an individual participant record.

Data collection

Between 30 October 2014 and 8 December 2014, 23 611 Birkie participants received an email invitation to participate in an online survey. The online survey explored demographics, health status and health behaviours (see Supporting Information). Health status and health behaviour questions were modelled after the Behavioral Risk Factor Surveillance System (BRFSS) and questions commonly used in the National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey (NHANES). Health status questions explored how participants would rate their current health status, how they felt their health compared with others, and whether they had any chronic conditions relevant to sport participation. Health behaviour questions explored topics such as nutrition, exercise habits, sleep patterns, smoking history and alcohol use. Self-reported demographic and physiological indicators were collected in order to calculate body mass index (BMI). This study was approved by the Mayo Clinic Institutional Review Board (IRB).

online questionnaire

Social support score

To calculate social support for exercise, we generally followed the validated method described by Sallis which arrives at a social support score by subtracting the values for negative social support questions from the values for positive social support responses.6 In this analysis, a support value was calculated for each of the 13 social support queries in question 10 (see Supporting Information) by assigning a numerical weight (0–4) to each response (eg, discussed exercise with me). We then added the total for family support and friend support to arrive at a support value for each query. For each social support query in question 10, the total value could be between 0 and 8. Further, to calculate the total social support score for an individual, we added together the support values from the 11 positive support queries and subtracted the values for the 2 negative support queries. Total social support scores for an individual in this study could range from −16 to 88.

Statistical analysis

We conducted descriptive analyses to summarise the survey respondents' demographics, health status, health behaviours and social support for exercise. Simple and multiple logistic regression models and linear regression models were constructed to evaluate the association between health status, health behaviours and social support. We adjusted age, gender, BMI, marriage status (married vs not married), employment (employed vs unemployed/retired), education (college degrees or above vs no college degree) and income (household income >$100 000 vs <=$100 000). Tests were deemed statistically significant if two tailed p<0.05. All statistical analyses were conducted using Stata V.13.1 (StataCorp, College Station, Texas, USA).

Results

Survey responses were received by 5433 participants (response rate=23%) and were included in analysis. Overall, survey respondents reported an average age of 47.9 years (SD=14.2, Range: 13, 88) and there was a slight predominance of males (64.5%) to females. The mean BMI was 23.8 (SD=2.9, Range: 15.1, 44.4) and the percentage of respondents who were obese was only 3.23%. The majority of respondents were married (71%), employed full-time (66.42%), college educated or above (86.2%), and slightly more than half had a household income greater than $100 000 (54.2%). Most participants reported very good/excellent health status (88.3%), that they were as fit or more fit than their peers (99.1%), that they were free of physical limitations (82.8%) and free from depression/low mood (93.1%).

Healthy behaviours were common in this group with only 14.4% eating vegetables less than one time daily, 18.8% eating fruit less than one time daily and only 5.84% reporting no leisure time physical activity. For other health status and health behaviour information, please see table 1.

Table 1

Demographics and biometrics for respondents to the Birkie health survey, 2015

Four questions in the survey asked about motivation for exercise. Over 95% of survey respondents reported that they are highly motivated to exercise by the simple act of signing up for the Birkebeiner or similar events. Many Birkie skiers (69%) are motivated to stay in shape by the thought that they are as fit or more fit than others in their same life situation (age, gender, etc). While exercising with others motivates Birkie skiers to sign up for races (75%), most reported that they would still sign up for races even if their family or friends did not do so (78%).

A slight majority of skiers reported that they most often train alone (53%), but during an average week most (70.85%) exercise with others at least once. The majority of skiers were introduced to Nordic skiing by a family member or a friend (79%) and many (35%) reported that they most often train with family or friends (table 2).

Table 2

Motivation and training patterns among American Birkebeiner participants

Social support scores

Overall, the mean social support score for all participants was 32.3 (SD=16.5; possible range=−16.0 to 88.0). For the various queries about types of social support, the most prominent form of social support was discussing exercise (mean=4.6, SD=2.2; possible range=0.0–8.0). Other prominent forms of social support included exercising together (mean=4.1, SD=1.9), offers to exercise together (mean=3.9, SD=2.0), talking about how much exercise is enjoyed (mean=3.7, SD=2.3), planning for exercise on recreational outings (mean=3.5, SD=2.2) and planning activities around the need for exercise (mean=3.0, SD=2.2). Negative social interactions such as complaints about exercising (mean=0.7, SD=1.1) and criticism for exercising (mean=0.5, SD=1.0) received very low scores. For the relationship between the various queries about types of social support, please see figure 1.

Figure 1

Mean score for each social support query among American Birkebeiner participants.

The relation of social support to health status and health behaviours

Individuals with high levels of social support were more likely to report very good/excellent health status (OR=1.31; CI 1.21 to 1.41; p<0.001) and less likely to report problems with depression/low mood (OR=0.84, CI 0.77 to 0.92; p<0.001). Each 10 point increase in the social support score was associated with a 5 min increase in weekly exercise time, and those reporting higher levels of social support were more likely to exercise greater than 150 min each week (OR=1.13, CI 1.08 to 1.18; p<0.001). Those reporting higher levels of social support were less likely to report less than once daily consumption of fruit (OR=0.88, CI 0.83 to 0.93; p<0.001) or vegetables (OR=0.78, CI 0.74 to 0.84; p<0.001). Increased social support scores were not significantly associated with tobacco or alcohol use or reports of no leisure time activity (table 3).

Table 3

Association between social support scores and health status, health behaviour

Discussion

While there are a few studies of motivation among professional Nordic athletes, ours study appears to be the first to provide a general profile of health and social support behaviours in a population of citizen Nordic skiers.8 ,9 Among Birkie skiers, the most common forms of social support were predominantly verbal such as discussing exercise, talking about the enjoyment of exercise and making offers to exercise with someone else. Exercising together, and making or changing plans around exercise were also very strong forms of social support. Social learning theory would suggest that social support through verbal processing helps skiers overcome barriers that involve motivation, the technical aspects of training and racing, and helps transmit ‘cultural’ elements of Nordic skiing such as trail etiquette, personal resilience and lifestyle behaviours important to better performance.

The behaviour of adjusting plans in order to exercise with others and exercising together may address even more barriers to training. While much social support was reported as verbal, Birkie skiers also reported significant support from regular group exercise. While a slight majority of respondents train alone most of the time (53%), most report exercise with others at least once weekly (71%). Further, respondents would still sign up for races without friend or family support, but do gain some motivation to race from training with others. While these responses seem difficult to reconcile, it may be that on the one hand the predominance of solitary training coupled with the determination to sign up for races regardless of social support suggests a high level of self-efficacy. On the other hand, the pattern of weekly exercise with others and the fact that skiers do sign up for races because of motivation derived from others suggests that any pre-existing self-efficacy may be reinforced by regular doses of exercise-specific social support.

Exercise-specific social support has been found to increase exercise adherence more than generalised social support and family and friends are particularly influential in this process.10 ,11 The majority of respondents in our study (79%) lend support to this idea since they report that they were specifically introduced to Nordic skiing by a family member or friend. Further, some of the most common social support behaviours in our survey involved planning for exercise on recreational outings and scheduling activities around exercise, both of which presume strong exercise-specific social support from friends and family.

In addition to social support patterns, our study explored the relationship between social support, health status, health behaviours and exercise patterns. Studies of runners in the USA and Switzerland have previously documented elevated health status and increased healthy behaviours in these populations.4 ,12 Our survey revealed many of the same patterns of elevated health status in skiers, and also revealed a positive relationship between overall social support and weekly minutes of exercise. In general, for every 5 min increase in weekly minutes of exercise reported, there was a 10 point increase in the self-reported social support score. In addition, reporting of depression/low mood was less likely to report strong social support (OR=0.84, p<0.001). These findings point to a positive link between physical activity levels and social connection and underscore the importance of physical activity promotion efforts that emphasise group activities, especially participation in strong fitness cultures.

Limitations

Self-reporting of exercise is an important limitation in our study and some of our questions on motivation have not been validated. Actigraphy studies show that people report far more physical activity than they actually perform when measured with an accelerometer. The positive relationship between self-reported weekly minutes of exercise and social support score is valuable for hypothesis generation, but in future studies it would be valuable to give participants an activity-monitoring device and a social support survey to see if there is a relationship between social support and monitoring data. In addition, we did not collect physiological data or examine medical records from participants and this limits our ability to characterise the actual health status of our participants. Future studies could involve simple physical examination, chart reviews and basic physiology testing for a subset of participants. Dietary recall is also difficult and this may have caused an overestimation of fruit and vegetable intake in this group. Future studies could use a formal 24 h dietary recall form, a weekly food diary or an online programme.3 The relatively low response rate of 23% might raise concerns about the precision of our study, potential nonresponse bias and the overall inferential value of our study findings. However, recent evidence suggests that a high response rate may not be the best predictor of overall survey quality.13 ,14 Nonetheless, generalisations from our study findings should be made with caution. Finally, the survey was internet-based and some individuals who do not use the internet regularly may not have received or completed the study. This may have excluded some older skiers or those without internet service.

Conclusions

Patterns of social support for exercise in Endurance Nordic skiers reveal the importance of verbal processing and regular group exercise for the initiation and maintenance of a physically active lifestyle. While endurance athletes appear to have high levels of self-efficacy, they also appear to draw on social support to bolster their motivation and skills and overcome barriers to better performance, especially support from family and friends. These insights drawn from exercise-specific social support in Nordic skiers are valuable for clinicians and public health practitioners attempting to promote increased physical activity. Those wanting to initiate, maintain or increase physical activity regimens should receive guidance that emphasises the importance of physical activities in groups, especially family of friend groups connected to larger fitness cultures that often surround community races or large national or international competitive events.

References

View Abstract

Footnotes

  • Contributors PJA, RSB and MHM contributed to the study design. PJA, TJB and MHM developed the survey. ZW analysed the results. PJA wrote the initial draft of the manuscript. PJA, RSB, ZW, TJB and MHM revised the manuscript.

  • Funding This research received no specific grant from any funding agency in the public, commercial or not-for-profit sectors.

  • Competing interests None declared.

  • Ethics approval The study was approved by the Mayo Clinic Institutional Review Board (IRB #: 14-003594) prior to implementation.

  • Provenance and peer review Not commissioned; externally peer reviewed.

  • Data sharing statement No additional data are available.

Request permissions

If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.